โ† Back to News
Newspaper Bakeries

The 5 Best Bakeries in Amherst, NY (Locals Swear By These)

By Sophia Ramirez|Posted: Apr 17, 2026 / 9:59 AM UTC|Updated: Apr 18, 2026 / 8:49 PM UTC

We rounded up the best bakeries in Amherst โ€” locally loved and worth every visit.

WHY IT MATTERS: Supporting local bakeries businesses keeps money in the Amherst community.

Amherst is home to a variety of delicious bakeries. 1. Paula's Donuts โ€” Amherst. Known for their wide selection of creative donut flavors, must-try item: the famous Paula's Donuts maple bacon donut. 2. Five Points Bakery โ€” Buffalo (serves Amherst), a popular spot for bread and pastries. 3. The Original Charlie the Butcher's Kitchen โ€” Amherst, also offers a variety of baked goods. 4. Tim Hortons โ€” Amherst, a well-known Canadian bakery and coffee chain. 5. Tops Friendly Markets โ€” Amherst, has an in-store bakery offering a range of fresh-baked goods. Be sure to visit these spots and support local businesses.

๐Ÿ“ฌ Buffalo's Daily Briefing
Like this story?
Get Buffalo's top stories delivered every morning โ€” free, no spam.

๐Ÿ’ฌ Comments

Sign in to join the conversation

The 5 Best Bakeries in Amherst, NY (Locals Swear By These) โ€” Stroubly